So there you have it... I chose white!
Thanks for all of the advice!
The reveal tomorrow and what I added to refresh these Ikea side tables.
But first a quick tip:
When I paint furniture or anything I like to elevate it off of the table or floor. For these side tables I used thumb tacks to elevate them up off of the table. This lets the paint all the way to the bottom, but the tables won't stick to the drop cloth while they are drying!